Well, I think in the US offering exams on a state-by-state basis would be morally (and legally) indefensible. Because people will just change their exam location from a highly infected state to a less infected state and travel, thereby spreading the virus across state lines. That can’t (and won’t) be allowed to happen.
For this reason I think the exams in the US have to go ahead on a national basis or not at all. Most likely the latter.
Having exams operate just in Europe, say, might be more viable, because the US rapidly became the global virus epicentre and, as Americans are now persona non grata all over the world, it’s almost impossible to leave the US to travel anywhere. In short, very few places now countenance letting Americans in (one notable exception being the UK, post-Brexit, which, unlike EU27 nations, allows Americans in subject to two weeks quarantine). So, CFAI could allow the exams to proceed in Germany, say, because Americans can’t get into Germany to write the exams and there is, consequently, no risk of Americans spreading the virus into Germany.
The question of fairness remains. But it would be harder to sue the CFAI for unfairness than suing for spreading the virus and causing illness and death.
Projections are for 30,000 Covid deaths in America this month. Half the number of Americans killed in Vietnam or ten 9/11s. I just don’t see the exams happening.
Increasingly, it also looks like we will never eradicate this clever and efficient little virus. Or it may take decades, as with polio. It seems any vaccine will only mitigate the effects of this and reduce its spread. We may be seeing a seminal dividing line in human history. Pre-Covid and post-Covid. In the same way we have the pre-internet and post-internet eras. This may not be just a blip. It may be the future.
CFAI should, if they are going to cancel the exams, do so sooner rather than later. And not allowing people to switch to June 2021, right now, is reprehensible. My guess, though, is that candidates will be strung along for some time yet. There is money at stake.
More fundamentally, CFAI needs to develop a strategy for what happens if Covid endures for many years hence. Whether that is online exams, like the UK’s IFoA, or continuous testing, as with the uniform CPA. The current CFAI exam model doesn’t work if, as seems likely, this thing is not going away.