Option 1: A machine with a useful life of 3 years that requires an initial investment of $32,500. The investment is expected to return $13,700, $15,900 and $17,000 during its three years of useful life respectively.
Option 2: A machine with a useful life of 4 years that requires an initial investment of $40,000. The cash flows from the investment equal $12,000, $14,500, $25,000 and $7,000 respectively
NPV of Option 1: -32,500 + PV(13,700)+PV(15,900)+PV(17,000) = $4,507.79 NPV of Option 2: -40,000+ PV(12,000) +PV(14,500) + PV(25,000) + (7,000) = $4,516.73 Checking EAA of Option 1: $1,876.81 EAA of Option 2: $1,487.05 Hence, Hagen should choose option 2.
My QSN is, I thought you choose the option with the Highest EAA OPTION 1